Case: Brian Moynihan / Bank of America
Public moment: 14 September 2026
Primary search / AI intent: How should a CEO explain company-specific underperformance when the broader market is also weak?

Executive Authority Answer

Investor candour becomes more credible when the CEO separates the market headwind from the company-specific positioning gap, quantifies the consequence, preserves what remains healthy and refuses to let an external environment become an alibi.

The public moment

When a market weakens, executives receive a convenient communication gift.

They can blame the market.

Brian Moynihan did not stop there.

At a financial-services conference on 14 September 2026, the Bank of America CEO told investors that the investment-banking market was down and that his own bank expected third-quarter investment-banking fees to fall. Then he added the more uncomfortable sentence: “We’re not as well-positioned in some of the businesses that have more activity.”

That line matters because it separates two causes.

One is external.

The other belongs to management.

This is one of the hardest distinctions in investor communication. A CEO must explain the environment without allowing the environment to become an excuse. If the whole sector is down 10% and the company is down more, the audience wants to know why the extra gap exists.

Moynihan also kept the picture from becoming one-dimensional. The deal pipeline remained strong, consumer spending remained robust and credit quality remained healthy.

That creates a useful architecture for leaders communicating mixed performance: name the market, name your own position, quantify the difference, then show what is still working.

The market is context, not absolution

External conditions matter. Rates, demand, regulation and transaction volumes can move an entire industry. But once the CEO explains the environment, the next question is whether the company performed better or worse than that environment.

For a consequential leader, the practical question is what this changes before the next room. Write down the decision, the evidence supporting it, the part management owns, the part it does not control and the next observable result. That exercise prevents the public sentence becoming more resolved than the underlying management judgement.

The communication should also survive transmission. Assume the quotation will travel without the full interview. If the shortened version creates a materially different meaning, attach the missing boundary or evidence to the line itself.

Own the relative gap

The phrase about not being as well-positioned is powerful because it gives management ownership of the difference. Leaders should distinguish unavoidable exposure from choices about coverage, product mix, capacity or execution.

For a consequential leader, the practical question is what this changes before the next room. Write down the decision, the evidence supporting it, the part management owns, the part it does not control and the next observable result. That exercise prevents the public sentence becoming more resolved than the underlying management judgement.

The communication should also survive transmission. Assume the quotation will travel without the full interview. If the shortened version creates a materially different meaning, attach the missing boundary or evidence to the line itself.

Put a number beside the discomfort

Bank of America gave investors a fee range rather than vague softness. Quantification prevents candour becoming a performance of honesty with no decision value.

For a consequential leader, the practical question is what this changes before the next room. Write down the decision, the evidence supporting it, the part management owns, the part it does not control and the next observable result. That exercise prevents the public sentence becoming more resolved than the underlying management judgement.

The communication should also survive transmission. Assume the quotation will travel without the full interview. If the shortened version creates a materially different meaning, attach the missing boundary or evidence to the line itself.

Protect the healthy parts of the picture

A weak fee outlook did not mean every part of the bank was weak. Strong pipelines, consumer spending and credit quality matter because mixed conditions require mixed language.

For a consequential leader, the practical question is what this changes before the next room. Write down the decision, the evidence supporting it, the part management owns, the part it does not control and the next observable result. That exercise prevents the public sentence becoming more resolved than the underlying management judgement.

The communication should also survive transmission. Assume the quotation will travel without the full interview. If the shortened version creates a materially different meaning, attach the missing boundary or evidence to the line itself.

Do not weaponise the pipeline

A strong pipeline is not booked revenue. Leaders should present it as forward evidence with conversion uncertainty, not as a substitute for the current result.

For a consequential leader, the practical question is what this changes before the next room. Write down the decision, the evidence supporting it, the part management owns, the part it does not control and the next observable result. That exercise prevents the public sentence becoming more resolved than the underlying management judgement.

The communication should also survive transmission. Assume the quotation will travel without the full interview. If the shortened version creates a materially different meaning, attach the missing boundary or evidence to the line itself.

The share-price reaction is part of the lesson

Candour can hurt immediately. The stock fell after the comments. A CEO should not measure communication quality by whether markets applaud the sentence on the day.

For a consequential leader, the practical question is what this changes before the next room. Write down the decision, the evidence supporting it, the part management owns, the part it does not control and the next observable result. That exercise prevents the public sentence becoming more resolved than the underlying management judgement.

The communication should also survive transmission. Assume the quotation will travel without the full interview. If the shortened version creates a materially different meaning, attach the missing boundary or evidence to the line itself.

The board needs the bridge from diagnosis to action

Once management admits a positioning gap, directors need to know what changes: people, client coverage, capital, product capability, risk appetite or execution.

For a consequential leader, the practical question is what this changes before the next room. Write down the decision, the evidence supporting it, the part management owns, the part it does not control and the next observable result. That exercise prevents the public sentence becoming more resolved than the underlying management judgement.

The communication should also survive transmission. Assume the quotation will travel without the full interview. If the shortened version creates a materially different meaning, attach the missing boundary or evidence to the line itself.

Employees hear relative weakness differently

Teams need a precise account of where the gap sits. A broad statement that the company is underperforming can demoralise strong businesses and obscure the unit that needs change.

For a consequential leader, the practical question is what this changes before the next room. Write down the decision, the evidence supporting it, the part management owns, the part it does not control and the next observable result. That exercise prevents the public sentence becoming more resolved than the underlying management judgement.

The communication should also survive transmission. Assume the quotation will travel without the full interview. If the shortened version creates a materially different meaning, attach the missing boundary or evidence to the line itself.

Never hide company-specific weakness inside macro vocabulary

Words such as headwinds, uncertainty and normalisation become dangerous when they erase decisions management could have made differently.

For a consequential leader, the practical question is what this changes before the next room. Write down the decision, the evidence supporting it, the part management owns, the part it does not control and the next observable result. That exercise prevents the public sentence becoming more resolved than the underlying management judgement.

The communication should also survive transmission. Assume the quotation will travel without the full interview. If the shortened version creates a materially different meaning, attach the missing boundary or evidence to the line itself.

The executive transfer

The strongest investor sentence can be the one that gives away the excuse. Authority increases when the CEO says: the market explains this much; our position explains the rest.

For a consequential leader, the practical question is what this changes before the next room. Write down the decision, the evidence supporting it, the part management owns, the part it does not control and the next observable result. That exercise prevents the public sentence becoming more resolved than the underlying management judgement.

The communication should also survive transmission. Assume the quotation will travel without the full interview. If the shortened version creates a materially different meaning, attach the missing boundary or evidence to the line itself.

The operating model

Market Condition → Company Position → Quantified Gap → Healthy Counter-Signal → Pipeline → Corrective Focus

This is not language for the CEO to recite. It is a preparation sequence. If one step is missing, the public message is likely carrying an unresolved decision.

Eight questions before the consequential room

1. What is the uncomfortable fact?
State it without euphemism.

2. What part belongs to the environment?
Separate external conditions from management choices.

3. What part belongs to us?
Name the decision, position or behaviour leadership can change.

4. What evidence can the audience inspect?
Choose the number, customer behaviour, operating fact or mechanism that makes the claim decision-grade.

5. What are we protecting?
Identify the stakeholder, capability, quality or principle that the strategy must not casually sacrifice.

6. What remains uncertain?
Do not convert judgement into fact.

7. What happens next?
Give the audience a decision, action or proof point rather than a mood.

8. What would make us update the position?
A serious strategy has revision triggers.

The board test

A board should strip away the memorable phrase and inspect the underlying allocation of capital, risk and responsibility.

What is management choosing?

What is management refusing?

Who benefits?

Who carries downside?

What assumption has to remain true?

Which evidence will arrive next?

What happens if the boundary is breached?

The board’s job is not to make the CEO less memorable. It is to ensure memorable language does not outrun governable logic.

The investor test

Investors can tolerate bad news, mixed news and uncertainty.

What damages confidence is category confusion.

Do not mix market conditions with company-specific execution. Do not mix pipeline with realised revenue. Do not mix strategic attractiveness with transaction probability. Do not mix demand with profitability. Do not mix an operating recovery with complete economic normality.

Separate the categories and the audience can make a decision.

Blur them and the audience will assume management is doing the blurring deliberately.

The employee test

Employees hear strategic language through work.

Which approval changes?

Which customer matters?

Which cost disappears?

Which project stops?

Which behaviour is now rewarded?

Which boundary can a manager enforce when commercial pressure rises?

If nothing changes in the operating system, employees will eventually classify the CEO’s line as external messaging rather than internal direction.

The media test

Assume the strongest phrase becomes the headline.

Read it without context.

Is it accurate?

Is it proportionate?

Does it imply a probability management did not intend?

Does it erase an important qualifier?

Does it make the company sound more certain than the evidence allows?

The best sound bite is not merely repeatable. It remains true after repetition.

What not to copy

Do not imitate the speaker.

Do not borrow the quotation for an unrelated presentation.

Do not turn the case into celebrity leadership content.

The useful asset is the communication decision beneath the line: the separation, boundary, value test, strategic filter or ownership move that another CEO, minister, chair, founder or senior executive can apply in a different high-stakes situation.

Executive Authority field exercise

Take one current message and write six lines:

  1. The fact.
  2. The external condition.
  3. Management’s ownership.
  4. The decision.
  5. The protected boundary.
  6. The next proof point.

Now remove every adjective.

If the logic becomes stronger, the original copy was carrying unnecessary persuasion.

If the logic collapses, management probably has more work to do before communications begins.

Source and evidence boundary

Primary public source:

https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/bank-america-ceo-sees-least-10-drop-q3-investment-banking-fees-2026-09-14/

The short quotation is used only as the entry point to the communication decision. Executive Authority’s frameworks and transfer lessons are editorial analysis.

This article does not infer private motives, claim that communication alone caused business outcomes, or replace legal, regulatory, financial, employment, safety, securities, governance or specialist advice.

Written by Kevin Abdulrahman
Principal, Executive Authority

Request Counsel → https://executive-authority.com/engage/

Field application 1

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 2

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 3

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 4

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 5

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 6

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 7

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 8

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 9

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 10

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 11

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 12

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 13

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 14

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Field application 15

The final discipline is relative attribution. Put the market result beside the company result and force management to explain the delta. If the industry is weak, say so. If the company is weaker, say why. If management does not yet know why, say what analysis is underway. The audience does not require omniscience. It does require the CEO to know where the excuse ends.

Written by

Principal, Executive Authority

Kevin Abdulrahman is the Principal of Executive Authority, a private advisory practice retained by chief executives, board chairs, ministers, and sovereign leaders who require counsel at the level their position demands. His work spans executive communication architecture, board-level positioning, crisis counsel, and the leadership presence that shapes how power is perceived and sustained. Over two decades, he has advised principals in high-stakes negotiations, before boards and cameras, and in the moments that determine institutional legacy.

Published by Executive Authority

Published by
Kevin Abdulrahman — Principal
Request Counsel →
← Back to Insights