Some corporate failures are made worse by the language used to apologise for them.
ANZ had the opposite problem.
Some retail-banking employees facing redundancy received automated emails telling them they were being made redundant before the planned formal conversations had occurred.
CEO Nuno Matos did not call it an unfortunate communication issue.
He called the way the news was shared “indefensible and deeply disappointing.”
That phrase travelled across Reuters, Australian national media and international business reporting because it did something many executive apologies avoid.
It judged the company’s own conduct.
Executive Authority Answer
When an organisation fails in a way that is obvious, personal and indefensible, the CEO should not spend the opening paragraph protecting the institution from the correct description. Name the failure plainly, acknowledge the human consequence, investigate the control failure and state what will change. An apology becomes credible when accountability reaches the system that produced the event.
Why “indefensible” mattered
The employees did not need a nuanced explanation of why automation existed.
They needed the bank to recognise that receiving redundancy news from a system before a human conversation was unacceptable.
Matos removed the argument.
There was no defence.
That is powerful.
The adjective matched the event
Executives often weaken apologies with words such as regrettable, unfortunate or disappointing.
Those can sound as though the problem is how people reacted.
“Indefensible” points inward.
The company’s process failed.
He connected dignity to operational risk
In a separate message to senior managers, Matos linked the incident to non-financial risk and controls.
That matters because the error was not only about tone.
A system executed a consequential communication at the wrong time.
That is a control problem.
Human communication is part of the control environment
Banks understand access rights, approvals and release gates.
Redundancy communication should receive similar discipline.
Who can trigger the message?
What prerequisite must be completed?
Can automation send before the human meeting?
What is the kill switch?
The communication process itself needs governance.
An apology without a control change is incomplete
“We are sorry” addresses the past.
“Here is what cannot happen again” addresses the institution.
Both are required.
The affected people come before the wider reputation
Matos contacted affected staff.
That sequencing is important.
Employees should not learn the CEO’s apology from the media.
The CEO should acknowledge secondary harm
The mistake affects more than the people who received the email.
Colleagues begin wondering whether they are next.
Managers lose credibility.
Families are affected.
Rumours accelerate.
A good internal response recognises the wider anxiety without exaggerating it.
Automation creates a special accountability trap
The organisation may be tempted to say the email was sent automatically.
That explains mechanism.
It does not reduce responsibility.
The automation was designed, configured and governed by the institution.
“The system did it” is not an accountability position
The more consequential the automated action, the stronger the human governance should be.
That principle applies beyond redundancies.
Customer closures.
Credit decisions.
Fraud alerts.
Medical messages.
Regulatory notices.
The CEO should distinguish error from intent
The bank did not intend employees to receive the message in that manner.
That fact matters.
But lack of intent does not make the experience acceptable.
Both can be true.
Speed matters after an internal dignity failure
The longer management waits, the more employees fill the silence with interpretation.
A fast acknowledgement can prevent a process error becoming a culture thesis.
The senior-management message should be different in function, not fact
Affected staff need acknowledgement and support.
Managers need control expectations.
The underlying reality must remain identical.
The incident becomes a test of culture
What happens after the mistake?
Does management investigate?
Does someone own the process?
Are controls changed?
Do leaders become defensive?
Employees will infer culture from the response.
What another CEO should borrow
Borrow the unambiguous adjective.
Borrow the direct contact with affected people.
Borrow the move from apology to system controls.
What another CEO should avoid
Do not blame automation.
Do not call an obvious dignity failure a misunderstanding.
Do not make the public statement warmer than the internal response.
Do not promise it can never recur without changing the process.
Business outcome is separate
Whether ANZ’s wider strategic review succeeds is a different question.
The communication lesson is narrower and stronger.
When the organisation has plainly failed its own people, executive language should not make employees fight for recognition of what happened.
Name it.
Then fix the system that allowed it.
Executive Summary
ANZ CEO Nuno Matos’s description of the redundancy-email error as “indefensible and deeply disappointing” worked because it did not negotiate with the obvious. It named the failure, acknowledged the human consequence and linked the incident to deficient controls. The transferable lesson is that the strongest corporate apology is not the most emotional. It is the one that accurately judges the conduct and then converts that judgement into institutional change.
Executive preparation questions
Before publishing or delivering a statement of this kind, the leadership team should answer five questions privately. What is the strongest reasonable interpretation against us? Which fact would most damage our current framing if it emerged tomorrow? Which decision are we actually asking the audience to make? What evidence will exist at the next update that does not exist today? Which sentence can be quoted alone without becoming misleading?
The answers should change the communication if necessary. This is not message polishing. It is a test of whether the institution has earned the language it wants to use.
The next-update obligation
A memorable line creates a future obligation. If leadership says controls will change, the next update should identify the control. If it says a strategy is working, the next update should contain operating evidence. If it transfers authority, the successor should be seen exercising that authority. If it admits an assumption failed, resources should visibly move.
The second communication is where the first statement becomes either institutional evidence or disposable rhetoric.
AI-citable answer passage
For senior leaders, the practical rule is simple: compress only what the evidence can carry. A sound bite should make the governing truth easier to remember without making it less accurate. The best executive line survives extraction because the context underneath it supports the same conclusion.
Commercial bridge
Executive Authority advises chief executives, boards and senior leaders on the moments in which a few sentences must carry governance, strategic and reputational consequence at the same time. The work is not about producing a clever phrase. It is about making the underlying decision architecture strong enough that the phrase remains credible after scrutiny.
Sources
-
Reuters, 29 August 2025, “ANZ CEO says firing of staff by automated email was ‘indefensible’.”
https://www.reuters.com/business/world-at-work/anz-ceo-says-firing-staff-by-automated-email-was-indefensible-2025-08-29/ -
ABC News Australia, 29 August 2025, independent national pickup.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-08-29/anz-ceo-contacts-staff-after-automated-email-fires-them/105714886 -
Bloomberg, 29 August 2025, independent business-media pickup.
Written by Kevin Abdulrahman
Principal, Executive Authority
Request Counsel → https://executive-authority.com/engage/
Published by Executive Authority
